arguments history news

<< Back home
<< Back overview

Article #5: His Master's Voice
Open letter to Mick Brown
by HH Shamar Rinpoche

This is the fifth article in a series of responses to Mick Brown's The Dance of 17 Lives: The Incredible True Story of Tibet's 17 th Karmapa (Bloomsbury , 2004).




IIIIIIIII Date: 02.08.2004

Mr. Mick Brown

c/o Bloomsbury Publishing Plc

38 Soho Square

London WID 3HB

United Kingdom

July 12, 2004

Dear Mr. Brown:
I am writing to ask you a question about something concerning me that you mention in your recent book.

The book by
Mick Brown

You say that I received a donation of $25,000 from a donor in New York City:

[Shamar] also had a gift for raising funds. One Western devotee recalls being with him in New York, in an apartment on 5th Avenue, with a wealthy sponsor, and he extracted this $25,000 donation, just like that. He had enormous charm and personality. It was just his way.  (The Dance of 17 Lives, p. 103)

I can understand clearly that your rhetorical target here is the phrase it was just his way.  I see that you are trying to portray me as some kind of businessman lama.

But my concern here is the accuracy of this story. I do not recall any of the details that you retell here. I never had such a meeting. I never received this donation at such an apartment in New York City. And I do not recall any donor who would have given it to me. To me, this whole story sounds invented.

I understand if you do not wish to divulge the name of the supposed devotee  who told you this story. But I would like to ask you to kindly disclose to me the name of this supposed donor. Perhaps I should make sure that I truly received the funds you mention.

Otherwise, if you cannot provide me with this information, then I will have no choice but to consider this anecdote an intentional misstatement on your part, intended to harm my reputation.


HH Shamar Rinpoche


If you don't want to miss the next part of the responses please join our mail-list!


    home I arguments I politics I history I contact I © KTC 2004